🏠 Home
Web Cornucopia (Finance)
📊 Education

🏦 Complete Banking Stock Analysis Masterclass

From Screening Failures to Professional Investment: Master Banking Analysis with Real Data

⏱️ 25 min read 🏷️ Banking Analysis 📊 Professional Framework 📅 Saturday, July 13, 2025

🚀 From Screening Disaster to Banking Mastery

You've learned the 10-pointer stock screening framework. Excited, you apply it to banking stocks and... disaster. ICICI Bank fails the debt-to-equity test. HDFC Bank shows negative operating cash flow. Even SBI's current ratio looks terrible.

Here's the uncomfortable truth: Standard stock screening frameworks don't work for banks. But here's the exciting opportunity: Once you master banking analysis, you unlock access to one of India's most profitable and predictable investment sectors.

Today, we'll transform you from confused screener to banking investment expert using real Q1 FY25 data from ICICI Bank, HDFC Bank, and SBI.

🎯 What You'll Learn

🏦

Banking Framework Mastery

Learn why standard screening fails for banking stocks and master professional banking analysis frameworks

📊

Real Data Analysis

Professional data extraction from Q1 FY25 results of ICICI Bank, HDFC Bank, and SBI with live examples

🎯

Banking-Specific Metrics

Master NIM, CASA, NPA, Provision Coverage, and other critical banking ratios for investment decisions

💡

Professional Methodology

Learn the "Saturday Afternoon Method" used by professional analysts for banking stock analysis

🚀

Investment Framework

Build systematic investment decision frameworks specifically designed for banking sector analysis

💥 Why the 10-Pointer Framework Breaks Down for Banks

Understanding the fundamental differences that make banks unique

🚫 Debt-to-Equity Ratio

Problem: Banks ARE debt businesses. Their entire model is borrowing money (deposits) and lending it out.

Reality: A D/E ratio below 10 would mean the bank is barely functioning!

🚫 Operating Cash Flow

Problem: When banks give loans, cash goes out (negative cash flow) but assets increase.

Reality: Growing banks often show negative operating cash flow, which is actually good!

🚫 Current Ratio

Problem: Banks have different liquidity requirements and regulatory frameworks.

Reality: Banks use CAR (Capital Adequacy Ratio) instead of current ratio.

✅ Modified Banking Screening Framework

From our original 10-pointer framework, we keep these criteria that actually work for banks:

  • Market Cap > ₹50,000 Cr - Focus on established players
  • ROE > 12% - Banking efficiency indicator
  • NIM > 3% - Core profitability metric
  • Gross NPA < 3% - Asset quality threshold
  • CASA Ratio > 35% - Low-cost funding indicator
  • Capital Adequacy > 12% - Regulatory safety buffer

⚠️ The Banking Screening Paradox

Even with our modified framework, most screening platforms don't provide banking-specific data like NIM, CASA ratio, or NPA metrics. This creates a catch-22: we need different criteria for banks, but the tools don't support them!

📊 Professional Data Extraction: The Investor Presentation Method

How professionals actually get banking data (not from Screener.in)

🎯 Live Demo: ICICI Bank Q1 FY25 Data Extraction

Follow this exact process to extract professional-grade banking data

Step 1: Google Search Strategy

Search: "ICICI Bank investor presentation Q1 FY25"

Result: Takes you directly to ICICI Bank official website → Investor Relations → Q1 FY25 Presentation

Step 2: Navigation Mastery

🌐 ICICI Bank Website: About Us → Investor Relations → Quarterly Results → Q1 FY25

📄 Download: "ICICI Bank Q1 FY25 Performance Review" (usually 60-80 page PDF)

Step 3: Data Location Mastery

✅ NIM: Usually Page 7-10 (Key Highlights section)

✅ CASA Ratio: Page 13-15 (Deposit Composition)

✅ Gross NPA: Page 25-30 (Asset Quality section)

✅ ROE: Page 5-8 (Financial Highlights)

Pro Tip: PDF Search Technique

Use Ctrl+F and search for: "NIM", "CASA", "Gross NPA", "ROE" to instantly locate metrics

Why Investor Presentations Beat Quarterly Reports

Quarterly Reports: Raw data, complex calculations required, difficult navigation

Investor Presentations: Pre-calculated ratios, visual charts, management commentary, easy-to-find metrics

The "Saturday Afternoon Method"

Professional analysts dedicate 2-3 hours every weekend to download latest quarterly presentations, extract key metrics, and update comparison spreadsheets. This manual process provides deeper insights than any automated screener.

📈 Real Q1 FY25 Banking Analysis: ICICI vs HDFC vs SBI

Let's analyze actual data from the three banks using professional extraction methods

🏆 ICICI Bank (Private Leader)

Market Cap: ₹10,28,293 Cr
Q1 FY25 NIM: 4.36%
Q1 FY25 ROE: ~18.5%
Gross NPA: 2.15%
CASA Ratio: 40.5%
Capital Adequacy: 16.66%

🥈 HDFC Bank (Quality Focus)

Market Cap: ₹15,23,921 Cr
Q1 FY25 NIM: 3.44%
Q1 FY25 ROE: ~14.2%
Gross NPA: 1.33%
CASA Ratio: 36.3%
Capital Adequacy: 18.7%

🥉 SBI (Scale Leader)

Market Cap: ₹7,20,083 Cr
Q1 FY25 NIM: 3.22%
Q1 FY25 ROE: ~11.8%
Gross NPA: 2.21%
CASA Ratio: 44.9%
Capital Adequacy: 13.7%

🎯 Deep Dive: Understanding Banking Metrics with Real Examples

Master each metric with actual Q1 FY25 calculations and insights

Net Interest Margin (NIM)

Net Interest Income ÷ Average Total Assets

ICICI Bank Example: Q1 FY25 NIM of 4.36% vs industry average of 3.5%. Shows superior pricing power and asset-liability management.

CASA Ratio Magic

(Current + Savings) ÷ Total Deposits

SBI's 44.9% beats ICICI's 40.5%. Higher CASA = lower funding costs. Current accounts pay 0% interest, savings pay ~4%.

Gross NPA Quality

Gross NPAs ÷ Total Advances

HDFC Bank's 1.33% is best-in-class. Shows superior credit underwriting. Below 2% is excellent for large banks.

ROE Efficiency

Net Profit ÷ Shareholders' Equity

ICICI Bank's 18.5% shows efficient capital utilization. Above 15% is excellent for banking sector.

Capital Adequacy Safety

Total Capital ÷ Risk-weighted Assets

RBI Minimum: 11.7%. HDFC Bank's 18.7% provides strong safety buffer for future growth and regulatory changes.

Provision Coverage Strategy

Provisions ÷ Gross NPAs

Higher coverage = better prepared for losses. ICICI Bank's 78.5% means they've already accounted for most potential losses.

Real Calculation Example: ICICI Bank Q1 FY25 CASA Ratio Calculation: • Current Account Deposits: ₹1,90,438 Cr • Savings Account Deposits: ₹4,25,148 Cr • Total CASA: ₹6,15,586 Cr • Total Deposits: ₹15,20,309 Cr • CASA Ratio: (6,15,586 ÷ 15,20,309) × 100 = 40.5% Business Impact: • Cost of Current Account: 0% • Cost of Savings Account: ~4% • Cost of Term Deposits: ~6-7% • Weighted Average Cost: Significantly lower due to 40.5% CASA

⚡ Advanced Banking Analysis: Beyond Basic Metrics

Professional techniques that separate expert analysts from beginners

Trend Analysis: The 12-Quarter Method

Don't just look at one quarter. Track NIM, CASA, and NPA trends over 12 quarters to identify improving vs deteriorating banks. ICICI Bank's NPA improvement from 4.13% (2021) to 2.15% (Q1 FY25) shows sustained quality improvement.

Provision Coverage Strategy

Banks can manipulate quarterly profits through provisioning. Higher provision coverage (>75%) indicates conservative management. During crises, well-provisioned banks outperform aggressive banks.

Credit Growth vs Deposit Growth

Healthy banks maintain loan-to-deposit ratios of 70-80%. ICICI Bank's advances of ₹24.87 lakh Cr vs deposits of ₹23.79 lakh Cr shows balanced growth without over-leveraging.

Management Quality Indicators

Track management guidance accuracy, strategic vision clarity, and technology investments. ICICI Bank's digital transformation leadership gives sustainable competitive advantage.

💡 Professional Insight: The "ICICI Premium"

ICICI Bank trades at higher valuations than SBI because: (1) Superior ROE (18.5% vs 11.8%), (2) Better NIM (4.36% vs 3.22%), (3) Technology leadership, (4) Consistent management execution. Market pays premium for quality and growth predictability.

📊 Complete Investment Decision Framework

From screening to portfolio allocation - the complete process

Evaluation Criteria ICICI Bank HDFC Bank SBI Ideal Threshold
Market Cap (₹Cr) 10,28,293 15,23,921 7,20,083 >50,000
NIM (%) 4.36 3.44 3.22 >3.5
ROE (%) 18.5 14.2 11.8 >15
Gross NPA (%) 2.15 1.33 2.21 <2.5
CASA Ratio (%) 40.5 36.3 44.9 >35
Capital Adequacy (%) 16.66 18.7 13.7 >12
Investment Grade A+ A+ B+ A- or better

✅ Investment Decision Matrix

Aggressive Growth: ICICI Bank - Highest NIM, Superior ROE, Technology leadership

Quality & Safety: HDFC Bank - Best asset quality, Premium valuation, Conservative approach

Dividend & Scale: SBI - Highest CASA, Government backing, Dividend yield focus

🛠️ Practical Implementation: Your Banking Analysis Workflow

Step-by-step process for professional banking stock evaluation

Phase 1: Initial Screening (Modified Framework)

Apply banking-specific criteria: Market Cap >₹50,000 Cr, ROE >12%, Focus on scheduled commercial banks only (exclude NBFCs like Bajaj Finance)

Phase 2: Data Extraction Workshop

Download latest quarterly investor presentations for shortlisted banks. Create Excel comparison with NIM, CASA, NPA, ROE, and Capital Adequacy trends over 8-12 quarters.

Phase 3: Quality Assessment

Analyze asset quality trends, provision coverage strategies, management commentary quality, and technology/digital leadership initiatives.

Phase 4: Valuation Context

Banks trade on P/E and P/B ratios, but context matters. High ROE banks deserve premium valuations. Factor in regulatory changes and economic cycle positioning.

Phase 5: Portfolio Integration

Banking allocation: 15-25% of portfolio. Diversify across private (ICICI/HDFC) and public (SBI) for different economic cycles. Monitor quarterly for trend changes.

🔧 Platform Limitations & Workarounds

  1. Screener.in Limitation: No banking-specific filters. Use modified general criteria as starting point.
  2. Manual Data Collection: Download quarterly presentations manually. Time-consuming but provides deeper insights.
  3. Tijori Finance Alternative: Better banking filters but costs ₹5,000/year. Consider for serious banking investors.
  4. Excel Template Creation: Build your own banking comparison spreadsheet with key metrics and automated calculations.
  5. RBI Data Cross-Reference: Verify bank-reported numbers against RBI industry data for accuracy.

🚨 Critical Mistakes to Avoid in Banking Analysis

Learn from common errors that cost investors money

❌ Mistake 1: Confusing Banks with NBFCs

Error: Comparing ICICI Bank with Bajaj Finance in same analysis

Reality: Different business models, regulations, and risk profiles. Banks can accept deposits; NBFCs cannot.

❌ Mistake 2: Ignoring Consolidated vs Standalone

Error: Using consolidated numbers for banks with insurance/broking subsidiaries

Reality: For banking analysis, use standalone numbers to focus purely on banking operations.

❌ Mistake 3: Quarter-over-Quarter Noise

Error: Making investment decisions based on single quarter performance

Reality: Banking is cyclical. Focus on 8-12 quarter trends, not quarterly fluctuations.

❌ Mistake 4: Provision Coverage Blindness

Error: Focusing only on reported profits without checking provision adequacy

Reality: Banks can manipulate short-term profits through provisioning. Higher coverage indicates quality management.

🎯 Your Banking Investment Advantage

Master banking analysis and unlock access to India's most profitable sector. Banks offer predictable business models, regulatory protection, dividend income, and economic leverage. Quality banks compound wealth over decades.

Next Steps: Download Q1 FY25 presentations for ICICI Bank, HDFC Bank, and SBI. Practice the data extraction method. Build your banking comparison spreadsheet. Start your journey to banking investment mastery.

🔗 Key Takeaways & Advanced Applications

Your banking analysis mastery checklist

✅ Banking Analysis Mastery Checklist

  • Modified Screening: Use banking-specific criteria, not general 10-pointer framework
  • Professional Data Sources: Investor presentations beat screening platforms for banking data
  • Core Metrics Focus: NIM, CASA, NPA, ROE, Capital Adequacy are your primary tools
  • Trend Analysis: 12-quarter tracking beats single-quarter snapshots
  • Quality Recognition: High ROE banks deserve premium valuations
  • Risk Management: Provision coverage and capital adequacy indicate management quality

🚀 Advanced Banking Applications

Master these advanced concepts for professional-level banking analysis:

  • Credit Cycle Analysis: Position for different economic cycles
  • Interest Rate Sensitivity: Asset-liability duration matching impact
  • Digital Transformation: Technology leadership as competitive moat
  • Regulatory Change Impact: Basel III, priority sector lending effects

Remember: Banking analysis requires patience and systematic approach. The best banking investments are held for years, not quarters. Quality banks compound wealth through economic cycles while providing steady dividend income.

↑